What if the afterlife forced you to choose between your lifelong partner and your first love? That’s the heart-wrenching dilemma at the center of A24’s upcoming romantic comedy, Eternity, and it’s already sparking conversations. Starring Elizabeth Olsen, Miles Teller, and Callum Turner, this thought-provoking film explores a unique afterlife scenario: souls have just one week to decide where—or with whom—they’ll spend eternity. But here’s where it gets controversial: Joan (Olsen) must choose between the man she’s built a life with (Teller) and her first love (Turner), who’s waited decades for her arrival. It’s a premise that’s as intriguing as it is divisive, leaving audiences to ponder: What would you choose?
The full trailer, now available ahead of its fall release, offers a glimpse into this emotionally charged story. Alongside Olsen, Teller, and Turner, the film features a standout cast including John Early, Olga Merediz, and Da’Vine Joy Randolph, fresh off her Oscar win for The Holdovers. Co-written by Pat Cunnane and David Freyne (who also directs), Eternity boasts a script that earned a spot on The Black List—an annual honor for the best unproduced screenplays. And this is the part most people miss: it’s in good company, alongside upcoming titles like Him, David O. Russell’s Madden (starring Nicolas Cage), and Subversion with Chris Hemsworth and Lily James.
While Eternity doesn’t hit theaters until November 26th, it’s already generating buzz. Premiering at this year’s Toronto International Film Festival, the film received widespread acclaim, currently holding an impressive 86% on Rotten Tomatoes. But the real question is: will it live up to the hype? And more importantly, how would you decide in Joan’s shoes?
Joining Eternity in the late-2025 release slate are If I Had Legs I’d Kick You and Marty Supreme, both expected to make waves during awards season. But Eternity stands out for its bold exploration of love, loss, and the choices that define us. Is it a love story for the ages, or a controversial take on the afterlife? You’ll have to decide for yourself.
What are your thoughts on the Eternity trailer? Will you be lining up to see it this fall, or does the premise leave you on the fence? Let us know in the comments—we’re eager to hear your take on this emotionally charged, conversation-starting film!
